The Millenium. A look into the Future.



Synopsis.

The purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the three main views of the millennium. It is hoped that it will also in some small measure be able to highlight how the view a particular church holds to will greatly impact the manner and means in which they carryout their ministry.

As each position is examined it will be seen that each has good scriptural grounds for their stand and has sound historical support by differing theologians. The dispensational position will only be dealt with briefly due to the constraints of space but it should however become obvious that when looking at the question of how a church carries out it's ministry does in many ways will have a slightly different affect than historical premillennialism.

Discussion

In dealing with the issue of the millennium it becomes important from the outset to realise that not only is there three main views[1] as to how the millennium will be manifested but there are a myriad of sub-views that attempt to breakdown the event and in some cases twist it to suit ones own theology.

Image of the BibleIn the postscript to his book Robert Clouse[2] writes that the reason we need to spend so much time identifying our own position of the millennium is because the answer to that question will in many respects determine the way in which we see the church operating in the world. Not only will the way it operates be determined by this issue but also the mission of the church as we see it will be manifested in different ways[3].

To start on a topic such as this it is firstly important to compare and contrast the differing views of the millennium as expressed through Revelation 20[4] and other passages.

Firstly, what is commonly called the amillennial view holds as it basic premise that there is no millennium or period of peace and righteousness through which the church will pass leading up till the last days[5].

Because of their aversion to matter (based on a Greek understanding of matter and an allegorising of exegesis) the Alexandrian Fathers opposed millennialism, claiming that our hope lay in the heavenly rather than the earthly realm[6].

Lewis and Demarst list the specific order of events for those holding this view as: “Christ’s present spiritual reign over the church; increasing apostasy on earth; the Great Tribulation; Christ’s second coming with the deceased saints; the destruction of evil powers; the general resurrection of believers and unbelievers; the last judgement; the eternal state”[7].

The coming HorsemanThis is the view held by such notables as Augustine although he is claimed by both the post and amillennial camps[8]. In the City of God Augustine writes that the millennium should be interpreted as the six thousand year period between God’s creation of man and the second coming of Christ, preferring to assume the symbolic rather than the literal interpretation of Revelation 20[9].

He goes on to cite the author of The Book of Revelation as intending the thousand years to mean the whole of the history of humankind[10].

Regardless of whether Augustine is seen primarily as a amillennialist or not he was responsible for moulding the theological thinking on this issue for over a thousand years. Other great theologians from the Latin Fathers such as Leo the Great, Gregory the Great, Albertus Magnus, and Thomas Aquinas all took positions similar to Augustine against what was called the “Chiliasm” or millennialism of their day[11].

The Amillennial position wants to affirm that at the coming of Christ which is told of in Revelation 20 there will be only one return of Christ, one resurrection and one judgement[12]. Robert Clouse points out that “they also interpret the millennium mentioned in Revelation 20 as describing the present reign of the souls of the deceased believers with Christ in heaven”[13]. This has the strength of dealing with the issue of the saints and what the premillennialists would see as the first resurrection (Rev 20:5)[14].

RevelationsThe binding of Satan for instance is seen not as the total banishment of Satan during this thousand years by banishing him to the pit (Rev 20:3) as per the premillennial position but rather a limitation of his powers that enables the nations not to be deceived against the power of the gospel message[15]. This fits well with their view of good and evil developing side by side till the Lord suddenly returns to carry out the judgment[16].

The passage most often quoted in defence of the amillennial position is in Matthew 13:24-30,36-43. The story of the wheat and tares existing side by side till the harvest echoes the good and evil that amillennialists talk about.

On the important subject of what position the Jews will hold in the millennium the Amillennialists would insist that the promises and covenants made to Israel are being fulfilled spiritually in the church[17].

Origen was to reject out of hand any suggestion that the Kingdom of God had any physical qualities to it. He like Augustine was to side with a symbolic interpretation of the millennium[18].

Secondly, there is the postmillennial stance which holds firmly to the concept that the Kingdom of God is now in force and is being extended towards it fulfilment. Under the guidance of the Holy Spirit the world will be evangelised and ultimately Christianised[19].

This will all culminate with the return of Christ at the close of a long period of peace and righteousness called the millennium[20]. Thus the world will become a more Christlike place in which to live and evil although it will not be totally obliterated will however be bought under submission to a point where it is negligible[21]. This will be followed by a brief period of apostasy just prior to the advent of Christ during which Satan will let be free[22].

RevelationAgain Augustine is credited with holding this position, as mentioned earlier the amillennialists claim to have him among their authoritative experts. However Augustine did in fact teach that the millennium had already began and was to be seen as the entire period of man’s history[23]. This was also a view held by other theologians of the past such as Jonathan Edwards who writes, “this work will be accomplished by means, by the preaching of the gospel, and the use of the ordinary means of grace, and so shall be gradually bought to pass”[24].

Edwards explains that some will be converted and be used to bring others to faith just as Daniel 2:3 prophecies[25]. Likewise he uses the illustration of the mustard seed in Matthew 13 to show that it will be out of the smallest of nations that the Kingdom of heaven will grow. Quoting Zechariah, Edwards points to a glorious revival through the pouring out of the Holy Spirit[26].

This is in sharp contrast to premillennialism which would sees the world as not being won for Christ during the present time, rather seeing the millennium as coming after the advent of Christ (of which will be dealt with shortly)[27].

Postmillennialists hold to a similar view with regards to the binding of Satan as the Amillennialists. It will be a figurative binding in which his powers to sway the church and individuals from understanding the gospel will be limited.

Death on a HorseIn contrast to the fulfilling of the promises to Israel in a spiritual manner (Amillennial), the Postmillennial view is that God has no special place for Israel and that Old Testament prophecies about Israel apply to the church[28].

Thus the order of events for the postmillennial position would be: “a golden age of increasing righteousness; a brief apostasy; three and a half years of Great Tribulation; the personal return of Christ; the general resurrection of the dead; the last judgment; and the eternal state[29]”.

Finally, there is what has been commonly been called premillennialism. So complex is the series of events that Appendix A has been attached which lists a complete chronological set of events of the last times[30].

Without a doubt an area where premillennialism strongly disagrees with the other two positions is over the interpretation of Scripture. While both the Amillennial and Postmillennial camps are satisfied to own an allegorical or symbolic interpretation of the Revelation 20 passage and others, premillennialist's hold to a literal one thousand years and a literal confining of Satan to the abyss or pit[31].

ResurrectionThe Didache for instance writes of a time when false prophets and lawlessness will abound, to be followed by a time during which the Antichrist will deceive the world with wonders and signs[32]. This sounds clearly like the period of the Great Tribulation as expected by the premillennialist's.

Clouse notes that during history there has always been a definite leaning to one of the three positions outlined here. Premillennialism was for the first three centuries the predominant view[33].

Premillennialism has been divided into two distinct streams with historical premillennialism being the predominant view held up until the second half of the nineteenth century when a new form was introduced and articulated by J.N. Darby. This was to be called dispensational premillennialism[34]. For the purpose of this essay the main thrust will be looking at historic premillennialism but it is important to note that the dispensationalist (see Appendix B.) position divides Christ’s return into two phases[35] and places a big emphasis on the conversion of Israel. This will become evident in it’s importance when the view of the millennium and the mission of the church will be looked at later in the essay.

One main point of contrast of the three positions A, Post and Premillennial is that the latter divides the resurrection into two phases[36]. This can be seen in the series of events outlined in Appendix A. It has been noted earlier that both the Amillennialist's and the Postmillennialist's hold that there will be only one general resurrection at which all the believers and unbelievers will be raised[37].

John the Evanglist.The premillennialist's see the world gradually disintegrating as it travels towards the time of Great Tribulation. In this amillennialism agrees with premillennialism that the Scriptures do not promise the conversion of the world through the preaching of the gospel. Yet it agrees with postmillennialism that the coming of Christ ushers in the last judgement and the eternal state[38].

There is also agreement between Amillennialism and Premillennialism that the return of Christ is imminent, however the postmillennialist's hold that Christ cannot return until the world is converted or at lest the majority has come to accept Christ as Lord.

Signs are another important element of the Premillennial view point as they would expect the rise of the Antichrist and the Great Tribulation to occur prior to the millennium being ushered in.

As for Israel, it has already been seen that the Amillennialist's would hold to a spiritualising of the promises to Israel while the Postmillennialist's sees no special place for Israel as distinct from the church.

Turning now to what place Israel holds in the theology of the premillennialist it is found that they are divided over this issue. Some asserting that no future is to be found for national Israel while others see a distinction between prophecy directed to the nation of Israel and prophecy directed to Israel as the people of God (the church)[39].

Great Red DragonTo try and bring some kind of order to this it becomes important to highlight the major points over which there is disagreement between the three positions.

In summary, there is disagreement over the interpretation of the passage (literal or not), the fate of Satan, the fate of Jews and if and when they will be saved, whether there will in fact be a millennium at all, the number and timing of the resurrections, the time of Christ's return and the future of the church (does it gradually grow like the mustard seed or will the world gradually overtake the church).

It is now to this latter aspect that the thrust of this essay will turn. How will their view of the millennium affect their view of the mission of the church?

Robert Clouse points out that an individual who takes a premillennial view will generally be more pessimistic about society[40]. As the only hope for the world lies in the second coming of Christ they tend to try and read the signs of the time and to bring about certain things in an effort to hasten the day.

This is especially evident with the dispensational emphasis on the need for the evangelisation of the Jewish people.

Social action for instance is for the premillennialist low on their agenda because they see no hope for the lost of humankind in this world[41]. They would tend to hold a low view of the Kingdom of God and it’s presence in the world to day, preferring to save a persons soul but failing to save the person from social injustice and oppression.

Day of His WrathFrom personal experience it has been seen in this authors local church that the vast majority of members over the years have held a strong dispensational position and have as a result been big on the second coming but have failed historically to evangelise and build into the church the lost and hopeless.

This was also evident in a major inner city Sydney Baptist church which had held a strong premillennial view and was eventually closed due to becoming irevelant in it's context. This church meet for only one and half hours each Sunday and had no social action with the community in which it was located. Instead the emphasis was on saving the soul or calling them to judgement so as hasten the day of the Lord’s return[42].

This attitude is in contrast to the dual aspects of the Kingdom of God. The here and not yet element holds the secret for Holistic ministry not just as a service to human souls.

Premillennialist's also tend towards a separatist view of the church. Holding that it is contaminating to have contact with culture and thus would avoid learning of the Arts etc[43].

In contrast those of the postmillennial persuasion see the world as a mission field in which to work, evangelise and build people into the church. The fact that they see evil being gradually overcome by Christ means they are much more optimistic in their outlook and more inclined to become involved in social action and to take stands against oppression and inequality.

When looking at the Eighth Century prophets the theme of failing to stand for the oppressed was held as one of the reasons for the judgement of the nations and Israel alike.

Amillennialism like Premillennialism has the inherent problem of a very pessimistic view of life[44] and as such would suffer some of the inadequacies of premillenniumism.

Fall of the Rebel AngelsInterestingly, Albert Schweitzer held to the Amillennial position and believed that Jesus would reveal himself to those who would obey his commands[45]. His view of Christ although somewhat distorted however pushed him towards mission to the underprivileged and lost.

It is the inaugurated eschatology held by many Amillennialist's that can give hope for the church of today. The now and not yet aspect of the kingdom of God points the church towards it’s responsibility to not only save a persons soul but to carry out Holistic ministry here on this earth while we wait for the Lord’s return[46].

It would appear that the position that has the most to offer in today’s world with a view to ministry is the one that allows the Old Testament teaching of social justice and the New Testament command to take the gospel to all the nations.

It could be said in conclusion, that if a proper detailed analysis of the mission of the different churches in any country and their view of the millennium were to be carried out, the success that that church had in fulfilling the great commission would be intricately tied their millennial view point.

Appendix A.

1. That the Kingdom of God is not now in the world, and that it will not be instituted until Christ returns.Death on a Pale Horse

2. That it is not the purpose of the present gospel age to convert the world to Christianity, but rather to preach the gospel as a witness to the nations and so to warn them of and make them justly subject to judgment; also to gather out of all the nations God’s elect, the Church saints.

3. That the world is growing worse and will continue to grow worse until Christ comes to establish his Kingdom.

4. That immediately preceding the return of Christ there is to be a period of general apostasy and wickedness.

5. That we are now in the latter stages of the church age and that the return of Christ is near, probably to occur within the lifetime of the present generation.

6. That at Christ’s coming the righteous dead of all ages are to be raised in the first resurrection.

7. That the resurrected dead together with the transfigured living saints who are then on the earth are to be caught up to meet the Lord in the air.

8. That judgment of all the righteous then takes place, which judgment consists primarily in the assignment of rewards.

9. That before and during the tribulation period the Jews are to be restored to the land of Palestine.

10. That at the mere sight of their Messiah the Jews are to turn to Him in a national conversion and true repentance.

11. That Christ at his coming destroys the Antichrist and all his forces in the battle of Armageddon.

12. That after the battle of Armageddon Christ establishes a world wide Kingdom with Jerusalem as its capital, in which He and the resurrected and transfigured saints rule for a thousand years in righteousness, peace and prosperity.

13. That during this reign the city of Jerusalem and the temple are to be rebuilt, the feasts and fasts and the priesthood, ritual and sacrificial system reinstituted, though performed in a Christian spirit and by Christian worshippers.

John the Evangelist14. That the golden age also is to be characterised by the removal of the curse from nature so that the desert shall blossom as the rose and the wild ferocious nature of the beasts will be changed.

15. That during the Millennium great numbers of the Gentiles will turn to God and be incorporated into the Kingdom.

16. That while many remain unconverted and rebellious at heart they are not destroyed, but are held in check by the rod of iron rule of Christ.

17. That during the Millennium Satan is to be bound, cast into the abyss, and so shut away from the earth.

18. That at the close of the Millennium Satan is to be loosed for a short time.

19. That the Millennium is to be followed by a short but violent outbreak of wickedness and rebellion headed by Satan which all but overwhelms the saints and the holy city of Jerusalem.

20. That the forces of wickedness are to be destroyed by fire which is cast down from heaven.

21. That the wicked dead of all ages are then to be raised in the second resurrection, judged, and with the Devil and the wicked angels cast into hell.

That heaven and hell are then introduced in their fullness, with the new heavens and the new earth as the future home of the redeemed, which will constitute the eternal state.

**This Material extracted from Lewis and Demarest, Integrative Theology.**

Appendix B.

1. increasing apostasy in the church age.New Jerusalem

2. An any moment secret coming of Christ for deceased and living saints (the “rapture” in “the day of Christ,” 1 Thess. 4:13-18), which removes the Holy Spirit from the earth (2 Thess 2:7).

3. The marriage feast of the Lamb in heaven.

4. The seven year tribulation on earth (Daniel’s seventieth week), which involves divine wrath upon unbelieving Gentiles and disobedient Israel.

5. The terrible reign of the Anti-Christ.

6. The conversion of a remnant of Israel (the 144,000 of Rev 7:3-8).

7. The wide spread conversion of gentiles (Rev 7:9).

8. The battle of Armageddon.

9. The return of Christ with his saints in “the day of the Lord” (Matt 24:29-31; Rev 19) to destroy his enemies at Armageddon.

10. The conversion of the vast majority of the Jews.

11. The incarceration of Satan in the abyss.

12. The resurrection of the tribulation martyrs and the Old Testament saints who join the raptured church in heaven.

13. The judgement of Israel (Ezek 20:33-38).

14. The establishment of the theocratic kingdom (millennium) centred in Jerusalem, which will be populated by believers living at the second advent who will marry, reproduce, and die.

Seven Sleepers of Ephesus15. The final rebellion by Satan and the unsaved toward the close of the Millennium, followed by their defeat, Satan’s confinement in the bottomless pit , and the resurrection of believers who died in the millennium.

16. After the Millennium the unbelieving dead will be raised, judged at the great white throne and cast into the lake of fire.

Thus as John Darby taught, Christs return would come in two stages.

1. A secret coming for the saints at the rapture

2. A glorious coming with the saints at the close of the tribulation.

Darby held that the Great Tribulation was exclusively Jewish and thus did not concern the church.

**This material extracted from Lewis and Demarest, Integrative Theology.**


BIBLIOGRAPHY.

Augustine, St, The City of God. (translated by Henry Bettinson: London; Penguin Books, 1972).

Berkof, Louis, Systematic Theology. (Grand Rapids; Eerdmans, 1965).

Berkouwer, G.C., Studies in Dogmatics: The Return of Christ. (Grand Rapids; Eerdmans, 1972).

Boettner, Loraine, The Millennium. (Phillipsburg; New Jersey; Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Company, 1957).

Chadwick, Henry, The Early Church. (London; Penguin Books, 1967).

Clouse, Robert, G., The Meaning of the Millennium: Four Views. (Illinois; Intervarsity Press, 1977).

Edwards, Jonathan, The Works of Jonathan Edwards. (Revised by Edward Hickman.; 2 Vols.; London; The Banner of Truth, 1974, Vol 1).

Erickson, Millard J., Christian Theology. (Grand Rapids; Baker Bookhouse, 1994).

Finger, Thomas, N., Christian Theology. (2Vols; Scottsdale; Herald Press, 1985).

Holmes, Michael, W., ed. The Apostolic Fathers. (Trans by J.B. Lightfoot & J.R. Harmer; Grand Rapids; Baker Bookhouse, 1990).

Lewis, Gordon R. & Demarest, Bruce, A., Integrative Theology. (Grand Rapids; Zondervan, 1994).


Footnotes.

[1] Millard J. Erickson, Christian Theology. (Grand Rapids; Baker Bookhouse, 1994) 1205ff. Erickson looks closely at the three major positions: 1. Premillennial, Postmillennial and Amillennial.

[2] Robert G. Clouse, The Meaning of the Millennium: Four Views. (Illinois; Intervarsity Press, 1977).

[3] Clouse, 209. G.C. Berkouwer, Studies in Dogmatics: The Return of Christ. (Grand Rapids; Eerdmans, 1972) 291.

[4] Erickson, 1210.

[5] Loraine Boettner, The Millennium. (Phillipsburg; New Jersey; Presbyterian and Reformed Publishing Company, 1957) 109.

[6] Gordon R. Lewis & Bruce A. Demarest, Integrative Theology. (Grand Rapids; Zondervan, 1994) 372.

[7] Lewis & Demarest, 372.

[8] Boettner, 116.

[9] St Augustine, The City of God. (translated by Henry Bettinson: London; Penguin Books, 1972) 906f.

[10] Augustine, 908.

[11] Boettner, 116.

[12] Lewis & Demarest, 372.

[13] Clouse, 9.

[14] Clouse, 17.

[15] Lewis & Demarest, 372: Clouse, 162: Boettner, 116.

[16] Clouse, 9.

[17] Lewis & Demarest, 372.

[18] Lewis & Demarest, 372. : Henry Chadwick, The Early Church. (London; Penguin Books, 1967) 184. Here Chadwick state that “Epiphanius condemned in Origen above all his tendency to reinterpret apparently literal statements as spiritual symbols”.

[19] Boettner, 4.

[20] Boettner, 4.

[21] Erickson, 1206f.

[22] Erickson, 1207.

[23] Augustine, 906.

[24] Jonathan Edwards, The Works of Jonathan Edwards. (Revised by Edward Hickman.; 2 Vols.; London; The Banner of Truth, 1974, Vol 1) 605.

[25] Edwards, 605. The stone cut out of the mountain without hands gradually grows.

[26] Edwards, 605.

[27] Boettner, 16.

[28] Lewis & Demarest, 374.

[29] Lewis & Demarest, 375.

[30] Boettner, 142f.

[31] Erickson, 1207ff.

[32] Michael W. Holmes, ed. The Apostolic Fathers. (Trans by J.B. Lightfoot & J.R. Harmer; Grand Rapids; Baker Bookhouse, 1990) 158.

[33] Clouse, 9.

[34] Louis Berkof, Systematic Theology. (Grand Rapids; Eerdmans, 1965) 710.

[35] Thomas N. Finger, Christian Theology. (2Vols; Scottsdale; Herald Press, 1985) 169. Finger describes the two phases of the dispensationalist position: “The first will occur before the Tribulation and Israel’s conversion. At this point he will not descend all the way to earth but will rapture Christians to meet him in the air. This will mark the end of the church age. God will then reactivate the Kingdom program for Israel, which has been suspended from AD 33. The Great Tribulation will break out and many Jews(along with some other groups) will be converted. Next, Christ will return for a second time to defeat Antichrist, bind Satan and establish a Judeo-centric millennial kingdom. From then events will proceed as they do for historic premillennialism”.

[36] Finger, 168f.

[37] Lewis & Demarest, 372, 375.

[38] Boettner, 114.

[39] Lewis & Demarest, 378.

[40] Clouse, 209.

[41] Clouse, 210.

[42] Clouse, 210. Clouse makes note of the general attitude of winning the last soul so that Christ will return.

[43] Clouse, 211.

[44] Boettner, 118.

[45] Erickson,1158.

[46] Clouse, 177ff.






New and Updated Articles of Interest.
Sin and Forgiveness in the Psalms.Sin and Forgiveness in the Psalms.
What does the book of Psalms tell us about sin?
Who is my Neighbour?
Have you ever wondered who your Neighbour should be? Jesus teach us the we should love them.A sermon from Luke 10:25-37.
Understanding the Holy Spirit.
This a sermon I delivered on Sunday 26th May 2013.(My 40th Wedding Aniversary.)
The Resurrection of Jesus.
This a sermon I delivered on Easter Sunday 2013.
Who am I and why do I exist?
The answer to the question (Who am I and why do I exist?) lies within Psalm 8 and as each individual exegete studies the passage they will notice that there are numerous textual problems.
Sexuality in the Church.
Is there no joy to be found in the church today for homosexuals?
Alcoholism in the Family.
The object of this essay is to highlight the strategies a pastoral carer would use when responding to a call for help from a family with an alcoholic mother..
The Letter to Romans.
What was Paul's reason for writing to the Church in Rome?
The Canon of Scripture.
Critically Evaluate the Argument that the Canon of Scripture is Closed.
The Wrath of God.
What is a Paul's View of the Wrath of God? How can we apply this to the AIDS epidemic?